Toaster Oven or Additional (Retroactive) Sibling

Would you rather have a nice toaster oven or a new sibling (who would die a painful death)?

Considerations:

• The toaster oven is really nice. It will never burn anything, and never need to be cleaned.
• The sibling would be retroactively added, and would be included in all family memories/photos/etc.
  
• You would love this sibling as you do to other siblings.
• This sibling would be within 2 years of your age.
  
• The painful death would be in the future, and would consist of roughly a year of suffering.
  

Follow up Question (for those that have siblings): Would you rather have a/your current sibling die a painful death or have a nice toaster oven and never have had your sibling?

Considerations:

• The nice toaster oven is the same as described above, likewise is the painful death.
• If you elect to keep your sibling (and let him/her die a painful death), you retain all prior memories of said sibling.